Penelope Magic Toast Barrel Strength Toasted Bourbon

Penelope Magic Toast Barrel Strength Toasted Bourbon is a 110 proof straight bourbon whiskey from Penelope Bourbon, aged 5 years and finished in a second barrel with a Char 5 Heavy Toast treatment. Built on Penelope's 75% corn, 21% rye, and 4% malted barley mash bill, this release delivers brown sugar sweetness, toasted vanilla, and deeply caramelized oak in a higher-proof package that rewards both neat sipping and cocktail use.

Penelope Bourbon has built a reputation on creative barrel finishing, and the Toasted Series is where that philosophy shines brightest. Rather than relying solely on traditional new charred American oak, Penelope re-racks this bourbon into a freshly toasted barrel for extra maturation, layering in deeper caramelized wood character before bottling at barrel strength for a bigger, more concentrated pour.

Tasting Notes

• Nose: Brown sugar, toasted vanilla, cinnamon pastry, cocoa, deeply caramelized oak
• Palate: Rich vanilla, dark caramel, warm baking spice, toasted oak, a touch of dried fruit
• Finish: Long, with lingering oak char, cinnamon spice, and a sweet caramelized-sugar warmth from the elevated proof

Product Details

Perfect For

• Weeknight sipping: The rich caramelized oak and brown sugar sweetness make this a satisfying pour after a long day, no fuss required.
• Home bar essentials: Barrel strength bourbon is a must-have for anyone who likes to build cocktails with real backbone and depth.
• Gift ideas: A striking limited 2026 release that makes a memorable gift for the bourbon enthusiast who already has the basics covered.
• BBQ and game day: The bold spice and caramel notes hold their own alongside smoky, savory food and good company.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Penelope Magic Toast good for cocktails or best sipped neat?

It works well both ways. The 110 proof gives it enough muscle to stand up in a stirred cocktail like an Old Fashioned, while the caramelized oak and brown sugar sweetness also make it rewarding sipped neat or with a splash of water.

What makes the Toasted Series different from regular Penelope Bourbon?

The Toasted Series undergoes a secondary finishing step in a freshly toasted barrel with a Char 5 Heavy Toast treatment, adding an extra layer of caramelized, toasted oak flavor beyond standard new-charred-barrel aging.

How does this compare to other barrel strength bourbons?

If you enjoy higher-proof bourbons like Knob Creek Single Barrel or Wild Turkey Rare Breed, Magic Toast offers a similar bold intensity but with a distinct toasted-oak sweetness that sets it apart.

Is this bourbon a good value at this price point?

Yes, at under $85 for a 5-year-old barrel strength bourbon with secondary barrel finishing, it delivers a level of complexity and richness that competes with pricier limited releases.

You must be 21 years of age or older to purchase this product.